Reply to this topicStart new topicStart Poll

> On the controversy of the history exam question
willyho
µoªí©ó¡G May 20 2020, 06:13 ¡@
Quote Post


¤K«~©x
*****

µoªí¼Æ¡G 250
©ÒÄݸs²Õ¡G ¤@¯ë
µù¥U¤é´Á¡G 10-01-2003

¬¡ÅD¡G6
Án±æ¡G110


Original article
From a surface reading of the question, the controversy so to speak is in the statement "Japan did more good than harm to China during the period 1900-1945". What some reporting seem to miss out is what follows the statement, namely discuss using the sources provided and own knowledge. I think the reaction is due to not reading the statement properly, namely that it spans the whole of 1900 to 1945, which includes events such as the downfall of the Qing dynasty, the Xinhai revolution, the forming of the Republic of China, all the way to the end of WWII. There is little scope for discussion regarding the latter half of the specified period, but there is certainly room for the first half. Fact of the matter is, the more prominent revolutionaries did flee to Japan to avoid capture, the northern expeditions were partially funded by loans from Japanese corporations, as shown from one of the excerpts. 

As for the critical thinking part, I don't know. Is it to force the student to take a step into the grey zone, and look at the period without personal attachments? Is it to look specifically at the time period at what was already happening in China, and then compare the relative scale of harm done by Japan?

To me it feels that the controversy is due to some people who are deliberately trying to find controversies or create some when there are none
PMEmail Poster
Top
±ë¤Ñ¤§»R
µoªí©ó¡G May 22 2020, 19:08 ¡@
Quote Post


¦Ó¥ß«C¦~
******

µoªí¼Æ¡G 472
©ÒÄݸs²Õ¡G ¤@¯ë
µù¥U¤é´Á¡G 1-03-2008

¬¡ÅD¡G3
Án±æ¡G70



QUOTE
a)¤ò¿AªF¡G¡u§Ú´¿¸g¸ò¤é¥»ªB¤Í½Í¹L¡C¥L­Ì»¡¡A«Ü¹ï¤£°_¡A¤é¥»¬Ó­x«I²¤¤F¤¤°ê¡C§Ú»¡¡G¤£¡I¨S¦³§A­Ì¬Ó­x«I²¤¤j¥b­Ó¤¤°ê¡A¤¤°ê¤H¥Á´N¤£¯à¹Îµ²°_¨Ó¹ï¥I§A­Ì¡A¤¤°ê¦@²£ÄÒ´N¹Ü¨ú¤£¤F¬FÅv¡C©Ò¥H¡A¤é¥»¬Ó­x¹ï§Ú­Ì¬O¤@­Ó«Ü¦nªº±Ð­û¡A¤]¬O§A­Ìªº±Ð­û¡C¡K¡K¡v ¦õ¦õ¤ì¡G¡u¤µ¤ÑÅ¥¨ì¤F¤ò¥D®u«D±`¼e§»¤j¶qªºÁ¿¸Ü¡C¹L¥h¡A¤é¥»­x°ê¥D¸q«I²¤¤¤°ê¡Aµ¹§A­Ì±a¨Ó¤F«Ü¤jªº·l®`¡A§Ú­Ì¤j®a·P¨ì«D±`©êºp¡C¡v b)¤ò¿AªF¡G¡u¨S¦³¤°麽©êºp¡C¤é¥»­x°ê¥D¸qµ¹¤¤°ê±a¨Ó«Ü¤jªº§Q¯q¡A¨Ï¤¤°ê¤H¥Á¹Ü¨ú¤F¬FÅv¡A¨S¦³§A­Ìªº¬Ó­x¡A§Ú­Ì¤£¥i¯à¹Ü¨ú¬FÅv¡C³o¤@ÂI¡A§Ú©M§A­Ì¦³¤£¦Pªº·N¨£¡A§Ú­Ì¨â­Ó¤H¦³¥Ù¬Þ¡C¡v¡]²³¯º¡A·|³õ¬¡ÅD¡^ ¦õ¦õ¤ì¡G¡uÁÂÁ¡C¡v
c)¤ò¿AªF¡G¡u¡K¡K¡C½±¤¶¥Û¬O²Ä¤@¦ì±Ð·|§Ú¥´¥Mªº¤H¡A´N¬O«ü³o¤@¦¸¡C¤@¥´´N¥´¤F¤Q¦~¡C§Ú­Ì±q¨S¦³­x¶¤¡Aµo®i¨ì¤T¤Q¸U¤Hªº­x¶¤¡Aµ²ªG§Ú¦Û¤v¥Ç¿ù¡A³o¤£¯à©Ç½±¤¶¥Û¡C§â«n¤è®Ú¾Ú¦a²Î²Î¥¢±¼¡A¥u¦n¶i¦æ¤G¸U¤­¤d¨½ªø©º¡C¦b®yªº¡A¦³§Ú¡AÁÙ¦³¹ù©Ó§Ó¦P§Ó¡C³Ñ¤Uªº­x¶¤¦³¦h¤Ö©O¡H±q¤T¤Q¸U´î¦Ü¤G¸U¤­¤d¤H¡C§Ú­Ì¬°¬Æ麽­n·PÁ¤饻¬Ó­x©O¡H´N¬O¤é¥»¬Ó­x¨Ó¤F¡A§Ú­Ì©M¤é¥»¬Ó­x¥´¡A¤~¤S©M½±¤¶¥Û¦X§@¡C¤G¸U¤­¤d­x¶¤¡A¥´¤F¤K¦~¡A§Ú­Ì¤Sµo®i¨ì¤@¦Ê¤G¤Q¸U­x¶¤¡A¦³¤@»õ¤H¤fªº®Ú¾Ú¦a¡C§A­Ì»¡­n¤£­n·PÁ°ڡH¡v

PMEmail Poster
Top
§d¶W
µoªí©ó¡G May 24 2020, 23:44 ¡@µû»ù¡G+1
Quote Post


¥|«~©x
*********

µoªí¼Æ¡G 1,098
©ÒÄݸs²Õ¡G ¤@¯ë
µù¥U¤é´Á¡G 11-16-2009

¬¡ÅD¡G12
Án±æ¡G117


µL½×§A¬F¨£«YÂI¡A«YÂÅ«Y¶À«Y¤j¤¤µØ½¦«Y¤p¯»¬õ«Y´ä¿W¦Û¨M¤À¤l³£¦n¡A³£·|¦P·N¥_¨Ê嚟ºò·|µÂ²M­»´äûH±Ð¨|¬É¡A¨ä¹ê­»´ä³£¦^Âk¥ªËݦh¦~¡A³s¤¤¤p¾Ç±Ð¬ì®Ñ¥N²z¤j³¡¤À³£«Y±±¨î喺¤¤¸ê­I´ºûH¥Xª©°Ó¨ì¡]¤T¤¤°Ó¡^¡A³s¤¤¤p¾Ç¦Ñ®v³£¥R¥¸¦í¤@¯Z³s¼sªF¸Ü³£¥¼Á¿¦nûH·s²¾¥Á¦Ñ®v¡A¦n¦h¤p¾Ç³£¤w¸g±À¦æ´¶±Ð¤¤¡AÂI¸Ñ¥_¨Ê¤´µM¨M¤ßı±o«Y¡u¶Àµ·¦Ñ®v¡v¬~­»´ä¾Ç¥Í¸£¡H

­ì¦]«Y¦]¬°¥_¨Ê¹ï­»´ä§½¶ÕûH¨â­Ó»~§P¡A²Ä¤@­Ó»~§P«YÁöµM­^°ê³£¨«¥ª¤G¤Q¦~¡A¦ý«Y¥_¨Êı±o­»´ä±Ð¨|¬É¤´µM´Ý¯d¤@¤j¯Z´ä­^¾lÄ^¡A¦V¾Ç¥Í±Ð¨|¤Ï¤¤«ä·Q¡A»Ýª¾¹D喺­»´ä­nª£¤@­Ó¦Ñ®v«Y·¥«×Ãøª£¡A­nª£¤@­Ó¦Ñ®v«Y­n¸g¹Ln±øµ{§Ç¡AµLªð¤@¦~¥b¸ü³£­ø¨Ï¦®·Nª£¨ì¡A¦Ó­»´ä±Ð¨|¬É´N¦³¤@¤j¯Z¨Ì啲´ä­^®É¥N¯d©³ûH¤H¡A¥_¨Êı±o¥u­n´«¨«¥ª¨Ì¯Z¤H©ÎªÌ«ä·Q¤WãT¨î¥ªÊ\¦a­»´äûH¾Ç¥Í´N­ø·|ËݤϷP¤¤°ê¡A«ä·Q¤W·|¦P¤j³°ûH¾Ç¥Í®t­ø¦h¡A¨ä¹ê¨Ì­Óçܪk«YµL¿ù¡A·íªì©Ò¿×¤­¤Q¦~¤£ÅÜ«Y°²©w¥ª­»´ä·|ºCºC¦P¤j³°Ú»»ô¡AµL½×«Y«ä·Q¤W©w¬Fªv¤W¡A¦ý«Y¹L¥ª¤@½ü¥ýµo²{¤j÷i¡A­»´ä¤H¹ï¤¤°ê¤HûHÂkÄÝ·P¦Û±q¬F§ï¤è®×¥¢±Ñ«á¶}©l¤U¶^¡A©Ò¥H¥_¨Ê¥ýºCºC¶}©l¶i¦æ¹ï¤¤¤p¾ÇûHº¯³z¡A¥Ñ¥Xª©°Ó¬Æ¦Ü¨ì®Õªø¡A³£¥i¥H¨£¨ì¤¤Áp¿ì­I«áûH¼v¤l¡A¦ý«Y´N«Y¦]¬°¯Z´ä­^¾lÄ^©Ò¥H¥ýµLËݧ֨ª¤Æ¡C¦Ó¦pªG±±¨î¥ª­»´ä¯Z¦Ñ®v¡A¶}©l±À¦æ啲·R°ê¦P¤ù­±ûH¥Á±Ú¾ú¥v±Ð¨|ûH¸Ü¡A­»´ä¹j¤@¥N¤H¤S¯u«Y·|¤ñÊ\¦a¼vÅT¨ì㗎Ø{

·í¦~¤å¤Æ¤j­²©R®`¦º¥ªËݦh¤H¡A¤ò¿AªF¤@¦º¯Z¤H­Ó­Ó¶}¤ß¨ì喺¨ì¼y¯¬¡A¦ý«Y¹j¥ª¤@¥N¤H¤§«á¥ò¦³´X¦h¤H«YËݤϦ@¡H³s­J¿ü¶i³£¦Û¤v¦¨¬°¥ª¤¤¦@ûH¤@¤À¤l°Õ¡]­J¿ü¶i¦Ñ¨§«Y¦a¥D¡^¡A©Ò¥H¦pªG¤¤°ê±±¨îÅαШ|¦P·s»D¡A­»´äµ²ªG·s¤@¥N¥X嚟ûH¤H¨ä¹ê·|¦P¼s¦{¤@­Ó´¶³qûH¾Ç¥ÍµLÉA¤À§O

¥t¥~¤@­Ó«Y©Ò¿×ûH¥~°ê¶Õ¤O¤z¹w¡A·íªì¤W¦~啱啱¹B°Ê¶}©l®É§ÚÚ»¨ì³æ·s»D¸Ü¦³®ø®§¤H¤h«ü¥_¨Êı±o«Y¦³¥~°ê¶Õ¤O¹ª°Ê­»´ä¤H¡A¤j³¡¤À­»´ä¤H³£«Y¤ä«ù­×¨Ò¡A·í®É§Ú­ø«Y¦n«H¡A¥ò¤ßçܲߪñ¥­Â½Àðµn°O­Ó³sµn±b¸¹¤W¥hÚ»¤U³£·|ª¾­ø«Y¨Æ¹ê°Õ¡A¦ý«Y¥_¨Ê³ºµM´N«YËÝÄø¡A§¹¥þ»~§P­»´äûH¬Fªv§Î¶Õ¡A¥òçܦí°Ïij·|·|Ũì¦h¼ÆûHij®u¡Aµ²ªG¤j±Ñ¦¬³õ¡C¨ì¨Ì¤@¨è¥_¨Ê¤´µMı±o¤Ï°e¤¤«Y¥~°ê¶Õ¤O喺­»´äµo°Ê¦Ó¥ø¹Ï¥´À»¤¤°ê²{®É¬D¾Ô¬ü°ê¦¨¬°¥@¬ÉÅQ¥DûH¦a¦ì¡A¥ç¸ÑÄÀ¨ìÂI¸Ñ­n§å°«¤è¤è¸ÜÊ\°e¤l¼u¤ñ¥~°ê¬F«È¥´À»¤¤°ê

¥H¤WûH¨â­Ó»~§P´N¥i¥H¸ÑÄÀ¨ìÂI¸Ñªñ±Æ¥_¨Ê­nËݤ߫æ¦A¦¬ºò­»´äûH¬Fµ¦¡A¥_¨Ê­n³z¹L°ªÀ£¬Fµ¦¥h¹¥ªA­»´ä¡A¥H§K­»´ä¦¨¬°¬ü°ê¥i¥H¥Î嚟¥´À»¤¤°êûHÄw½X¡A¤@³õ¥þ¤è­±ûH¬Fªv§å°«¤s«B±ý¨Ó¡A¥Ñ°ê®õ¨ì¤¤¸ê¡A¥Ñ¤½°È­û¥h¨ì­»´äûH±Ð¨|¬É¡A­»´ä·Ç³Æ­n¶i¤J¤@­Óªñ¥G¤@°ê¤@¨îûH·s¯u¬Û®É¥N


--------------------
PMEmail Poster
Top
§d¶W
µoªí©ó¡G May 25 2020, 21:54 ¡@
Quote Post


¥|«~©x
*********

µoªí¼Æ¡G 1,098
©ÒÄݸs²Õ¡G ¤@¯ë
µù¥U¤é´Á¡G 11-16-2009

¬¡ÅD¡G12
Án±æ¡G117


QUOTE (±ë¤Ñ¤§»R @ May 23 2020, 03:08)
QUOTE
a)¤ò¿AªF¡G¡u§Ú´¿¸g¸ò¤é¥»ªB¤Í½Í¹L¡C¥L­Ì»¡¡A«Ü¹ï¤£°_¡A¤é¥»¬Ó­x«I²¤¤F¤¤°ê¡C§Ú»¡¡G¤£¡I¨S¦³§A­Ì¬Ó­x«I²¤¤j¥b­Ó¤¤°ê¡A¤¤°ê¤H¥Á´N¤£¯à¹Îµ²°_¨Ó¹ï¥I§A­Ì¡A¤¤°ê¦@²£ÄÒ´N¹Ü¨ú¤£¤F¬FÅv¡C©Ò¥H¡A¤é¥»¬Ó­x¹ï§Ú­Ì¬O¤@­Ó«Ü¦nªº±Ð­û¡A¤]¬O§A­Ìªº±Ð­û¡C¡K¡K¡v ¦õ¦õ¤ì¡G¡u¤µ¤ÑÅ¥¨ì¤F¤ò¥D®u«D±`¼e§»¤j¶qªºÁ¿¸Ü¡C¹L¥h¡A¤é¥»­x°ê¥D¸q«I²¤¤¤°ê¡Aµ¹§A­Ì±a¨Ó¤F«Ü¤jªº·l®`¡A§Ú­Ì¤j®a·P¨ì«D±`©êºp¡C¡v b)¤ò¿AªF¡G¡u¨S¦³¤°麽©êºp¡C¤é¥»­x°ê¥D¸qµ¹¤¤°ê±a¨Ó«Ü¤jªº§Q¯q¡A¨Ï¤¤°ê¤H¥Á¹Ü¨ú¤F¬FÅv¡A¨S¦³§A­Ìªº¬Ó­x¡A§Ú­Ì¤£¥i¯à¹Ü¨ú¬FÅv¡C³o¤@ÂI¡A§Ú©M§A­Ì¦³¤£¦Pªº·N¨£¡A§Ú­Ì¨â­Ó¤H¦³¥Ù¬Þ¡C¡v¡]²³¯º¡A·|³õ¬¡ÅD¡^ ¦õ¦õ¤ì¡G¡uÁÂÁ¡C¡v
c)¤ò¿AªF¡G¡u¡K¡K¡C½±¤¶¥Û¬O²Ä¤@¦ì±Ð·|§Ú¥´¥Mªº¤H¡A´N¬O«ü³o¤@¦¸¡C¤@¥´´N¥´¤F¤Q¦~¡C§Ú­Ì±q¨S¦³­x¶¤¡Aµo®i¨ì¤T¤Q¸U¤Hªº­x¶¤¡Aµ²ªG§Ú¦Û¤v¥Ç¿ù¡A³o¤£¯à©Ç½±¤¶¥Û¡C§â«n¤è®Ú¾Ú¦a²Î²Î¥¢±¼¡A¥u¦n¶i¦æ¤G¸U¤­¤d¨½ªø©º¡C¦b®yªº¡A¦³§Ú¡AÁÙ¦³¹ù©Ó§Ó¦P§Ó¡C³Ñ¤Uªº­x¶¤¦³¦h¤Ö©O¡H±q¤T¤Q¸U´î¦Ü¤G¸U¤­¤d¤H¡C§Ú­Ì¬°¬Æ麽­n·PÁ¤饻¬Ó­x©O¡H´N¬O¤é¥»¬Ó­x¨Ó¤F¡A§Ú­Ì©M¤é¥»¬Ó­x¥´¡A¤~¤S©M½±¤¶¥Û¦X§@¡C¤G¸U¤­¤d­x¶¤¡A¥´¤F¤K¦~¡A§Ú­Ì¤Sµo®i¨ì¤@¦Ê¤G¤Q¸U­x¶¤¡A¦³¤@»õ¤H¤fªº®Ú¾Ú¦a¡C§A­Ì»¡­n¤£­n·PÁ°ڡH¡v


¦³­Ó­p¶q¾ú¥v¾Ç¬ã¨sµo²{1937-45 ¨ä¶¡¤é­x¦û»â¹L¬J¦a°Ï¥X³Ì¦h¬J¦@²£ÄÒ­ûuser posted image, ¸Ô²Ó¬Jmethodology´N­ø°O±o¥ª,¦³¿³½ì¥i¥H¦Û¤vgoogle¤U


--------------------
PMEmail Poster
Top
1 ¦ì¨Ï¥ÎªÌ¥¿¦b¾\Ū¥»¥DÃD (1 ¦ì³X«È¤Î 0 ¦ì°Î¦W¨Ï¥ÎªÌ)
0 ¦ì·|­û¡G

Topic Options Reply to this topicStart new topicStart Poll

 



[ Script Execution time: 0.0132 ]   [ 12 queries used ]   [ GZIP ±Ò¥Î ]